|
What’s all This Talk about Homework and Grading?
Posted by Missy Bender
I have received more than a few emails from folks who have read or heard media stories about a review of homework strategies for Plano ISD middle school students. Each of them is asking what I think about separating student behavioral choices from academic grading.
What do I think?
The bottom line is very simple. I believe in an educational system that holds students to the highest standards of integrity. I do not support cheating or the absence of accountability nor do I believe that the grading committee would have made a recommendation that compromised accountability or integrity if the proper vetting process had occurred.
I steadfastly agree that every student should be prepared for a successful life in our democratic society. One of the key statements in the school district's belief statements regards excellence in education and states: "Responsible citizenship and character traits of integrity and ethics.” This is unwavering. Please don't be misled into thinking otherwise.
The Board of Trustees has had no discourse on this issue because it has received no recommendation. Make no mistake about it; I expect the highest level of integrity from Plano ISD staff and students. At all times. Period. There will never be compromise on that.
What happens now?
While there may be continuing study about middle school grading issues in the future, the current study will not progress further. In my mind, the committee process was flawed from the start because it did not have the participation of parents and community members. Though the work of the committee is appreciated, and has opened up interesting dialogue, this process is completed. It is, however, a good reminder that the district must use a model of community engagement when studying issues like this so that any outcome is reflective of community values and good educational pedagogy.
I take my role on this board and my reputation within my community very seriously. I stand for the highest ethical standards of accountability and integrity, and that is non-negotiable.
Read the statement on the Plano ISD web site on this this topic.
Posted April 13, 2009
| View
(3718 Views)
|